...

Part 2: When Neighbors Become Threats: A Prepper's Guide to Community Security

May 29, 2025
by Jason Salyer
GoOn3.com is provided for entertainment purposes only. Read our Entertainment & Liability Disclaimer.

When society breaks down, the greatest threat might be living right next door

In a world where chaos lurks just beneath the surface of civility, knowing who is knocking at your door might be the difference between survival and becoming another statistic.

The Friendly Face of Danger

Remember that neighbor who always borrowed your lawn mower but never returned it? Well, when SHTF, he might be eyeing more than just your yard equipment. I hate to break it to you, but that nice family next door with their perfectly manicured lawn and matching Christmas sweaters? They're exactly three missed meals away from becoming your worst nightmare.

Look, I'm not saying you should go full-on paranoid and start treating the HOA president like he's planning to raid your pantry (although, between us, I've always found something suspicious about a man that is passionate about lawn ornament regulations). But as any seasoned prepper knows, disaster doesn't just change circumstances—it changes people.

The Post-Collapse Personality Shift

Here's a hard truth that normies don't want to hear: when society crumbles, your neighbor's true colors will shine brighter than a tactical flashlight in a blackout. That quiet accountant down the street? He might be the first one trying to barter for your last can of beans and not with a calculator.

I've spent years building my preps, and if there's one thing I've learned, it's that desperate people do desperate things. And nothing makes people more desperate than watching their kids go hungry while remembering that you mentioned your food storage during last summer's block party.

Identifying Potential Threats Before Disaster Strikes

Let's be real, you can't prepare for neighbor threats without first knowing who might become one. Here are some red flags to watch for:

  1. The Resource Mooch: Always borrowing things but conveniently "forgetting" to return them. When disaster strikes, they'll remember exactly what you have. 
  2. The Gossiper: If they're sharing everyone's business now, they'll have no problem telling desperate strangers about your stockpile later. 
  3. The Anti-Prepper: The neighbor who mocks your "paranoia" today will be the first one banging on your door tomorrow. 
  4. The Flashy Consumer: Anyone who needs to show off their latest purchases probably hasn't saved a dime or a drop of water for emergencies. 
  5. The "We're All In This Together" Type: Sounds nice until you realize they mean "your supplies are our supplies." 

Building Community Defense Without Creating Targets

Now, I am not suggesting you turn into a complete lone wolf. There is strength in numbers if those numbers are trustworthy. The trick is finding the balance between helpful community members and naive resource donors .

I have spent over a decade methodically building my survival network, applying rigorous selection criteria that most people are too afraid to implement. Through organized work parties, high stress training scenarios, and deliberate resource scarcity simulations, my wife and I have identified who truly belongs in our inner circle when SHTF.

Let me tell you, nothing reveals character faster than seeing who hoards the water when they think supplies are running low, or who steps up to help others when everyone is exhausted from building emergency shelters for eight hours straight. We have quietly removed individuals from our prepper community who demonstrated selfishness, inability to handle pressure, or questionable decision making during these controlled scenarios. Better to discover these weaknesses during practice than during an actual collapse.

After years of community building experience, my wife and I developed the TRUST framework that has become the cornerstone of our member selection process:

T - Trustworthy: Can this person be trusted with knowledge of your supplies, your family's whereabouts, or sensitive security information? Trust is earned through consistent actions over time, not just words.

R - Reliable: Can you depend on this person in various situations? Do they follow through on commitments? Do they maintain operational security? Reliability means showing up prepared and ready when needed most.

U - Useful: What skills, knowledge, or resources does this person bring to the group? Everyone must contribute meaningfully to community resilience and survival capability.

S - Suitable: Does this person share your core values, cultural understanding, and beliefs? Conflicting worldviews become magnified during crisis situations and can tear communities apart precisely when unity is most critical.

T - Teachable: Can this person adapt when circumstances demand it? Are they willing to learn new skills and approaches? A teachable person acknowledges they do not know everything, actively seeks knowledge, and can function as both student and teacher as circumstances require.

Want to proudly display these principles and support our mission? Get your exclusive TRUST Framework shirts from my TSpring Shop! Each purchase helps fund our community preparedness initiatives and spreads the message that survival requires more than just gear. It requires the right people.

CLICK BELOW TO GET YOURS TODAY!

On Three

My approach? Selective transparency. Be helpful without broadcasting your preps. If someone's car won't start, help them out. If they ask what's in your basement, tell them your collection of vintage Star Wars figurines takes up all the space (works every time, nobody wants to talk about that for long).

The Gray Man Approach to Neighborhood Relations

The best defense against neighbor threats is often the "gray man" strategy: be unmemorable, unremarkable, and uninteresting. In everyday life, this means:

  • Keep prep-related deliveries discreet
  • Don't brag about your food storage or security measures
  • Participate in community events but avoid becoming the center of attention
  • Help others in small ways without becoming their go-to resource

Remember: you can be friendly without being a friend, and you can be helpful without being a hero.

When Politeness Fails: Setting Boundaries in Crisis

When the power's been out for a week and that neighbor who never returned your hedge trimmer shows up asking if you have "anything to spare," having pre-established boundaries will save you from making emotional decisions.

Decide now what your policy will be. Will you turn away everyone? Help only those with children? Provide limited assistance? The time to figure this out is before you have hungry faces staring at you through your peephole.

My personal rule: I help with knowledge before resources. Teaching someone to purify water is better than giving them your last bottle. It is the whole "teach a man to fish" concept, but with more tactical awareness.

Communication Networks: The Real Neighborhood Watch

One of the most overlooked aspects of neighborhood security is communication. In a crisis, information becomes as valuable as ammunition. Establishing a neighborhood communication plan  whether it's predetermined meeting spots, whistle signals, or amateur radio can transform potential threats into potential allies.

Just make sure those communication networks are secure. The last thing you need is to broadcast your emergency meeting location to every desperate person within earshot.

The Bottom Line: Prepare for the Worst, Hope for the Best

Look, I'd love to believe that when disaster strikes, we'll all join hands and sing kumbaya while sharing our freeze-dried stroganoff. But my money's on human nature doing what it's always done. Prioritizing survival over social niceties.

The hard truth is that some of your neighbors will become threats, some will become assets, and most will just become another problem to manage. Your job is to prepare for all three scenarios while hoping for the best.

Remember, in the prepping world, optimism is a luxury, but preparation is a necessity. So smile at your neighbors, wave when they drive by and keep your pantry location to yourself.

Because when the disaster hits the fan, the only certainty is uncertainty... and the knowledge that your neighbor's kid who keeps hitting baseballs into your yard might soon be eyeing more than just your garden gnomes.

Stay prepared, stay vigilant, and for goodness sake, stop telling people about your emergency supplies.

Want more no nonsense survival advice? Follow me for more informative resources:

  • Substack: Subscribe to my weekly newsletter and podcasts at Jason Salyer On Ready for great content and early warnings about emerging threats. 
  • YouTube: Head over to for detailed tutorials, gear reviews, and situation analysis you will not find anywhere else. 
  • Patreon: Support my mission to spread real preparedness knowledge and get access to my private community, exclusive guides, and monthly Q&A sessions. 

Remember, in a world of sheep, be the well prepared wolf. Your family, friends, and or community are counting on you.

This article is part of our "Uncomfortable Truths" series, where we tackle the aspects of prepping that others are too afraid to discuss.

P.S. Forward this newsletter to someone who needs to hear it. The prepping and survival community is filled with fantasies - let's spread some reality instead.

Check Out My Recommended Gear & Supplies

Explore the gear and supplies I personally use and trust. When you purchase through my Amazon storefront and other affiliates, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These small commissions help support the creation of informative, free content for you to enjoy.

Sign up for emails to get bug in and bug out information, practical prepping, survival tips, gear reviews and uncomfortable moments that lead to growth.

© 2025 goon3.com | The Reality Check Newsletter

Free E-Book

Don't Get Caught Unprepared - DOWNLOAD THE FREE EBOOK :

Tried and Tested: 6 Life-Saving Skills You Should Know Before You Head Outdoors
Free Ebook Form
BLACK FRIDAY SALE
Check It Out
Master the Skills, Own Your Freedom – Unlock Black Friday Savings on 
Top 10 Skills Every Man Should Master!
Learn the essential tools for self-defense, disaster readiness, and off-grid independence at an unbeatable price! TODAY ONLY!

Sign Up for the On3 Email Newsletter

https://www.youtube.com/@onthree
Seraphinite AcceleratorOptimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
Turns on site high speed to be attractive for people and search engines.